Microsoft Recall AI will log everything you do on Windows

zohaibahd

Posts: 124   +1
Staff
The big picture: Desktop users will swear they've been in situations where they had to desperately search through emails, browser histories, and file folders trying to find that one thing they vaguely remember seeing or working on a few days prior. It's frustrating, but Microsoft may have cracked this problem with a new feature called Recall.

Launching for the upcoming Copilot+ PCs powered by Qualcomm's Snapdragon X Elite chips, Recall is essentially an all-seeing eye that keeps tabs on everything you do on your computer. It then presents a scrollable timeline you can search through, using AI. In an interview with The Wall Street Journal, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella described the feature as an upgrade over traditional keyword search, dubbing it was "semantic search over all your history."

"It's not just about any document. We can recreate moments from the past," he said. He also provided a glimpse into what happens behind the scenes when the feature's turned on. Essentially, Windows takes screenshots of your screen constantly. It then uses a generative AI model right on the device along with the NPU to process all that data, including photos.

As an example, a Microsoft executive used Recall during a demo at its preview event this week to instantly pull up her recent Pinterest searches for "blue dress" just by saying that phrase out loud. With a couple more details like "sequined lace" and "for Abuelita," Recall homed in on the exact item she'd been eyeing.

As you can tell from the demo above, the level of data captured seems pretty vast. Recall's timeline lets you scroll through a visual recreation of everything you've done, seeing past browser sessions, video meetings, you name it. Meetings get automatically transcribed and translated too, thanks to Live Captions tech also integrated into Recall.

All this does sound kind of similar to the Cortana-powered Timeline feature Microsoft abandoned in Windows 10 a few years back. Despite its promise, the feature never caught on. And with Cortana's looming deprecation, it probably made sense to axe the whole thing at the time. But cut to now, with Copilot's improved generative AI powers, Microsoft thought it would revive the feature in a new avatar.

Of course, there may be some privacy implications here, too. Microsoft's laying those to rest by claiming all Recall data stays local and private on your PC, and you can pause or delete logging as needed. However, it added that Recall won't proactively hide sensitive stuff like passwords or payment details.

"Your snapshots are yours; they stay locally on your PC. You can delete individual snapshots, adjust and delete ranges of time in Settings, or pause at any point right from the icon in the System Tray on your Taskbar. You can also filter apps and websites from ever being saved. You are always in control with privacy you can trust," notes Microsoft.

There are some hardware limitations as well. Recall requires one of the freshly announced Copilot+ PCs with a special neural processing unit for the heavy AI lifting involved. And you'll need a decent chunk of storage too – Microsoft recommends a minimum of 256GB of space, with 25GB allocated to Recall out of the box for roughly 3 months of snapshots.

Performance is another open question. Could having an AI assistant perpetually logging all your activities affect battery life? We'll have to wait for real-world tests to know for certain.

Permalink to story:

 
No thanks. I don't need some crap program constantly wanting to write to my drives over and over again and I also don't want their "AI" crapilot+. They can keep this far away from me.

My use on my computer is for me and me alone, not for some asshat corp to take constant snapshots of what I'm doing. For some reason I just don't believe MS when they say it only stays on the user's computer......
 
No thanks. I don't need some crap program constantly wanting to write to my drives over and over again and I also don't want their "AI" crapilot+. They can keep this far away from me.

My use on my computer is for me and me alone, not for some asshat corp to take constant snapshots of what I'm doing. For some reason I just don't believe MS when they say it only stays on the user's computer......
I believe that it will stay on the computer for now. In the future, they will probably start taking bits and pieces for "telemetry".

I'm happy that I'm on Linux and don't have to deal with all of their bullshit.
 
1. Just wait until corporations start receiving subpoenas to turn over the complete Recall timelines (=screenshot every 3 seconds) for all their executives. I hope Microsoft is among the first to receive one.

2. In regular life, at least in some states, there are rules about what audio and video can be recorded without permission of all the parties. Is it OK for every Zoom call to be recorded and indexed, even locally? What about the inevitable next step where portions are forwarded for whatever reason?

3. Has Microsoft forgotten that it issues security patches almost every week, and has a not-short history of having to apologize to users and governments for "accidental" oversteps in meeting their stated commitments as to privacy, security, etc?

4. It's a real shame my current CPU and system will not meet the requirements for this feature.

5. I'll wear my tin foil hat with pride and say in all seriousness I believe there is a non-zero chance that one motivation for this "feature" was a substantial payment (or threat, or other leverage) from the NSA asking for it, and there are already APIs under discussion where they can search for or ask to be notified of snaps that meet their certain criteria (all via a totally legal and constitutional process involving a blanket top secret subpoena from a top secret court that includes attornies from only one side, publishes no opinions, and has no appeals process.)
 
I believe that it will stay on the computer for now.
The most optimistic you can be is to believe that is Microsoft's sincere intention, for now. But Microsoft's intent does not equal what will happen in the real world. At minimum, ransomware gangs and other hackers; family members with physical access to the device or account; and lawyers with subpoenas (or cops who just take stuff), will all have vast new data to play with.
 
The paragraph about the demo says a lot about the true intention: they want all your data and shove you some extra ads for your effort.
 
Unless some third party works out a way to disable this feature, I will avoid Windows 11 like the plague. I've never heard of many more moronic ideas but Nadella is a epic failure so nothing surprises me from Macroshit anymore.
 
No thank you! Sounds like a disaster in the making. If there are people that need this - they are actually the same people that should not use it (security and privacy).

"Recall won't proactively hide sensitive stuff like passwords or payment details."
 
There are privacy nightmares and then there's Recall AI. The latter one is worse.
As is the case with all AI, the issue is not with all the undeniable progress and benefic potential results of AI but with the fact you need only ONE a-h--e out of the 8 billion out there to find a way to use it for his own gain and purpose.
 
Even if they give you an off button, the next Update will probably switch it back on again. That sort of behaviour is so easy for them.
 
Back